Graveyard Baseball: Five years later: Grading the Seibu Lions 2016 Draft Class

===

The Saitama Seibu Lions had several pitching options to take in this draft, but there was a huge difference of opinion in the first round. Through three seasons, a few players have already made some impact while others continue to develop.

Here are the grades on the class after five seasons:

===

First round: P Tatsuya Imai (Sakushin Gakuin, Tochigi)

The Lions did not go for the hyped up Seigi Tanaka and all six B-class teams took a different player as a way of punishing those who went for him. There was no opposition for Imai's rights.

Imai's first season of professional baseball was cut short due to injury, where he suffered a shoulder problem in spring training camp. A suspension delayed his ichi-gun debut in 2018, but he made progress and continued to stay at the top level before being overwhelmed in the postseason. He put in a larger workload for 2019 while still developing, but remained inconsistent as a whole. In the last two years, it looks like he'll be a front end starter with a breakout season from being an ace.

Grade: A-

Hindsight: Taisuke Yamaoka has paid early dividends for Orix. Haruhiro Hamaguchi is a starter for the Baystars. Dragons took Yuya Yanagi in a coin flip draw. Hanshin took Yusuke Ohyama.

===

Second round: P Shunta Nakatsuka (Hakuoh University, Tochigi)

Nakatsuka failed to earn a roster spot during his five years in NPB. At one point, he almost finished a game being one out away, but three consecutive walks without a strike forced a hook. He saw two ichi-gun games in 2018 with no success and the same control problems continued to linger.

He also received a workload in Australia with the Melbourne Aces and again struggled with control out of the bullpen. In Australia, he was known as "The Big Man" due to his size. His last ichi-gun action had six games in 2020, before the Lions cut him after the 2021 season. Grade: F

Hindsight: Yuta Kuroki is a back end reliever for Orix. Yota Kyoda won the Central League rookie of the year award for the Chunichi Dragons. Tomohito Sakai was taken by the Marines and since switched to the Eagles as part of free agency compensation for Minabu Mima. Kazunari Ishii has been a regular fielder for the Fighters. Seishu Hatake has contributed for the Giants.

===

Third round: IF Sosuke Genda (Toyota Motors, Aichi)

The Lions took a shakaijin in the third round and he played every single inning at the ichi-gun level for 2017. Genda became the fourth player in NPB history to accomplish this feat and he won the 2017 Pacfic League rookie of the award. He avoided any sophomore slump in 2018 and became a Best IX SS for both the 2018 and 2019 seasons. COVID and injuries have limited Genda's playing time, but he's been the team captain since 2020 and an asset. Grade: A

Hindsight: None for now

===

Fourth round: OF Shohei Suzuki (Shizuoka HS, Shizuoka)

The Lions took a HS outfielder as a future prospect. Suzuki made good progress in ni-gun and the Lions like what they're seeing him, hoping he can develop into a potential leadoff hitter. He earned his first ichi-gun action in 2019 as a reserve outfielder and even saw a handful of starts in right field.

His role expanded in 2020 and 2021, but couldn't keep his starting spot. He will be 24 this year and time could be running out if he doesn't make an impact. Grade: C-

Hindsight: Orix took Yoshinobu Yamamoto. The Marines took Seiya Dohi. Dragons took Shotaro Kasahara.

===

Fifth round: P Katsunori Hirai (Honda Suzuka, Mie)

Hirai was one of the oldest players taken in the class as he was a shakaijin playing in Mie prefecture. He cracked the ichi-gun level in May of 2017 and never had to look back, earning innings in medium leverage. For 2018. he was part of a up and down bullpen where he was prone to giving up home runs.

In 2019, he earned the setup man role and thrived under Kazuyoshi Ono. However, his arm was shot by the end of the year by overplaying him in every role from leading by 1 run to tie games or even trailing by a few runs. By appearing in 81 games, it was a new Pacific League record. This season shot his arm while his role diminished. For a fifth round draft pick, there is still good value at finding a reliever Grade B-

Hindsight: Kohei Morihara was taken by the Eagles.

===

Sixth round: P Ichiro Tamura (Rikkyo University, Tokyo)

Tamura has mostly taken mop up innings while staying alive at the ichi-gun level. He even earned a win in 2021. Decent for a 6th round pick. Grade: B-

Hindsight: Rakuten took Yuhei Takanashi in the 9th round. Marines took Atsuki Taneichi. Baystars took Keita Sano in the 9th round.

===

Overall:

Imai appears to be the best high school pitcher in this class, while a starting SS in Genda to help immediately and a reliever in Hirai are all positive picks. All three players had a role in the success from 2018-2019. Grade: A-

===

Twitter results here:

#埼玉西武ライオンズ 2016ドラフトクラスの採点方法を教えてください?

How do you grade the #SeibuLions 2016 Draft class?

RT and spread @Cape_Lions @64Uni_Lions @nerimamo

#NPBeng #今井達也 #中塚駿太 #源田壮亮 #鈴木将平 #平井克典 #田村伊知郎
— Graveyard Baseball (@GraveyardBall) December 8, 2021